1971 · Over Lago de Cote, near Arenal, Alajuela province, Costa Rica

Lago de Cote: the disc on mapping frame 300

Sourced, unconfirmed
Strength B · 7/10 · 4 independent
Evidence 3/4 · Witnesses 2/3 · Backing 2/3

An official survey camera frame with its neighbours and data strip, a named photographer, and a published analysis with a dissenting referee; nobody saw the object.

Plausibility High
Score 11 · 7 factors for, 0 against

A government mapping camera caught a sharp disc on one frame that a published analysis could not explain; a referee's pressure-mark idea was rebutted and never tested on the original negative.

See the factors ↓

Natural cause proposed, not demonstrated
IGN aerial frame 300, 4 September 1971: the disc over Lake Cote, Costa Rica (crop of the 2022 drum scan). · Instituto Geográfico Nacional de Costa Rica, 1971; drum scan by Esteban Carranza (2022), via Wikimedia Commons

A Costa Rican government mapping photo taken from 10,000 ft on 4 September 1971 shows a sharp, shaded disc over Lago de Cote on a single frame, which nobody aboard saw and which Jacques Vallée and Richard Haines could not identify.

The frame came from a routine survey for the Arenal hydroelectric project. The camera fired on a timer, pointed down at the ground, and the frames on either side show the same lake with nothing over it. Haines and Vallée published their analysis in the Journal of Scientific Exploration in 1989. Fifty-five years after the flight, a documentary, The Cote Photo, put the photographer back in front of a camera.

The flight and the photographer

The Instituto Geográfico Nacional flew a twin-engine Aero Commander for the Costa Rican Electricity Institute that morning. Aboard were pilot Omar Arias, Francisco Reyes, Juan Bravo and aerial photographer Sergio Loaiza. The film's data strip reads "ARENAL", 10,000 ft, 4-9-71, with the camera clock at 08:25. None of the four reported anything unusual.

Loaiza says the object turned up only later, when the institute went back to the photos for a new study. A co-worker looking over the prints called out, as Loaiza tells it to La Nación in 2021: "Look, what the heck is this? It looks like a flying saucer." He told CR Hoy in 2016:

I remember we spread out the photos, put the negative in the enlarger, and found the UFO. At that moment we were totally forbidden to talk about it, and we couldn't tell anyone.
Sergio Loaiza, CR Hoy, 2016

He says they took an enlargement to the institute's director, who called in the head of the sister Geodetic Institute, and that official told them on the spot not to discuss the photo with anyone. In the same 2021 interview Loaiza describes later personal contact experiences of his own.

What the analysts found

Researcher Ricardo Vílchez obtained the photo and in 1979 sent it to Ground Saucer Watch in the United States, which judged it made in good faith, according to CR Hoy. One of the two authors saw it at a meeting in Costa Rica in 1985, and Vílchez gave them a second-generation negative to take home.

Haines and Vallée found the disc lit like a solid object, with a sharp edge on the sun's side and a diffuse edge on the other. They found no distortion of the film grain around it and no sign of a double exposure or fabrication. They also found no shadow on the ground. The camera's geometry caps the size: at ground level, 10,000 ft away, the object would be 210 m (683 ft) across at most. In their words, "the various analyses failed to identify the image", and they left the case open until more information came in.

The referee's dissent

The journal printed a dissent beside the paper. Its referee, Marilyn Bruner of the Lockheed Palo Alto Research Laboratory, judged the northern edge too sharp for a real object and proposed a pressure mark from a particle caught in the film roll. She named a test: examine the original negative under glancing light for dents or scratches. Haines and Vallée replied that rooftops on the same negative have sharper edges, and that a particle should have left matching marks on frames 299 and 301, which they could not find.

Where the negative is now

In 2022 lawyer Esteban Carranza had a drum scan made of a contact copy of the negative that he said came from the National Archive, according to IFLScience. The producers of The Cote Photo (76 minutes, directed by Adam Pillon with Megan Woomer, released on Apple TV on 4 September 2026) say its chain of custody is held at the National Archive. Leslie Kean is listed on the production team.

Pressure mark on the film proposed by the referee in 1989; not demonstrated.

Evidence, in date order

  1. 4 Sept 1971Instituto Geográfico Nacional de Costa Ricaphoto
    survey frame 300 with its data strip (clock 08:25, altimeter 10,000 ft, 'ARENAL', 4-9-71), plus frames 299 and 301 for comparison
  2. 1979Ground Saucer Watchdocument
    judged the photo made in good faith after Ricardo Vílchez sent it in 1979
  3. 1989Richard F. Haines and Jacques F. Valléedocument
    Photo Analysis of an Aerial Disc Over Costa Rica: enlargements, digital enhancement, sun-angle and shadow search on a second-generation negative Journal of Scientific Exploration 3(2), pp. 113-131
  4. 4 Sept 2026Archivo Nacional de Costa Ricadocument
    holds the photo's chain of custody, according to the producers of The Cote Photo; a contact copy of the negative came from the archive, according to Esteban Carranza (2022)

How plausible · High

A government mapping camera caught a sharp disc on one frame that a published analysis could not explain; a referee's pressure-mark idea was rebutted and never tested on the original negative.

  • ●●
    Access Government survey camera, fixed mount, looking down.
  • ●●
    No gain sought Nobody aboard saw it; the frame surfaced years later during routine photo work.
  • ●●
    Checkable details check out Frames 299 to 301 exist; the archive copy can be re-examined.
  • ●●
    Physical traces or official reaction The film itself.
  • ●○
    Restraint The crew reported nothing at the time.
  • ●○
    Character record Professional government cartographer; he later described personal contact experiences.

Plausibility weighs how well an account fits where secrecy hides the documents by design, so missing records never count against it. Strength measures what is documented. Assessed 2026-11-19.

Claims

One frame of a government survey run (frame 300) shows a sharp, shaded disc over the lake; frames 299 and 301 of the same ground show nothing, and none of the four men aboard saw anything.firsthandSourced, unconfirmedSergio Loaiza, aerial photographer on the Instituto Geográfico Nacional flight (CR Hoy 2016; La Nación 2021)
"I remember we spread out the photos, put the negative in the enlarger, and found the UFO. At that moment we were totally forbidden to talk about it, and we couldn't tell anyone."firsthandSourced, unconfirmedSergio Loaiza, interviewed by CR Hoy (2016)
The analyses failed to identify the image; there is no sign of a double exposure or a deliberate fabrication. If the object sat at ground level, 10,000 ft from the camera, it could be at most 210 m (683 ft) across.analysisSourced, unconfirmedRichard F. Haines and Jacques F. Vallée, Journal of Scientific Exploration 3(2), 1989
The oval image is more likely an artefact such as a pressure mark from a foreign particle in the film roll than a photo of a physical object. Natural cause proposed, not demonstrated.analysisSourced, unconfirmedMarilyn E. Bruner (Lockheed Palo Alto Research Laboratory), referee's review in the same issue
On 25 October 1986 two farm workers saw a row of dark post-like cylinders rise about 3 ft out of the lake and sink back with turmoil and waves.firsthandSourced, unconfirmedtwo farm workers named by initials, interviewed two weeks later by Ricardo and Carlos Vílchez, as reported by Haines and Vallée (1989)

People and organizations

Sources

Similar and linked cases

Want to dig?

The Workspace has every case, person, document and episode, with the board, the atlas, timelines and the threads between them.

Open the Workspace →
Sources include war.gov/ufo (PURSUE), the FBI Vault, NASA and ASU Apollo archives, congressional testimony and the witnesses' own words. Each case links to its sources.A research project · updated 22 November 2026 · Privacy