News show episode · Reality Check · 2025

Reality Check: Michael Herrera on the Sumatra craft, the NDA and the emptied camera

Reality Check episode thumbnail. · NewsNation, YouTube thumbnail

Reality Check's 2025 episode in which Ross Coulthart interviews former Marine Michael Herrera about the octagonal craft and armed, unmarked team he says he met during the 2009 relief operation near Padang, Sumatra. Coulthart opens by vouching for him: "I know Michael Herrera is telling the truth."

Herrera adds the paper and the aftermath. The NDA a lieutenant colonel in Air Force blues slid in front of him on Okinawa showed only "TS/SCI" and "Indonesia" as far as he could read. Back on ship after liberty at Subic Bay, his camera lay on his rack with the battery out and the memory card gone, though his locker was untouched, and his teammates' phones were missing too. One of the five other Marines told him by message to "shut up"; another emailed to thank him "for getting the word out". He gave all their names to the Senate Intelligence and Armed Services committees and to AARO, and was told they are only "incidental witnesses".

Coulthart puts it to him that Jake Barber recognised the containers Herrera describes as the kind used at "the range" to transport psionics; Herrera answers "Correct." He describes photographs of himself driving to work sent to his house, helicopters over his home and business, and a statement to Homeland Security agents interested in trafficking. Unnamed engineers who built such craft, he says, have contacted him and want to come forward, and unnamed people "on the back end" confirmed Jonathan Weygandt's 1997 Peru event, with the Department of Energy possibly involved. Will Congress ever call him, or the five men with him that day?

Cases discussed

Timeline

On the recordWitness testimonyAlleged / one person's word
People across the timeline · click a name or a dot
2000sHerrera 2
Oct 2009
Camera emptied on the shipBattery out, card gone, locker untouchedSumatra, 2009: Michael Herrera's octagonal craft
Oct 2009
NDA on OkinawaOnly 'TS/SCI' and 'Indonesia' legible to himSumatra, 2009: Michael Herrera's octagonal craft

The claims, checked

Witness testimony

The NDA he signed for the Air Force lieutenant colonel on Okinawa showed only 'TS/SCI' and 'Indonesia' among what he could read; he wrote his name and Social Security number on it.firsthandSumatra, 2009: Michael Herrera's octagonal craft
Back on the ship after liberty at Subic Bay, he found his camera lying on his rack with the battery pulled out and the memory card gone, though his locker had not been disturbed; the other Marines' phones were also missing, and nobody else's in the platoon.firsthandSumatra, 2009: Michael Herrera's octagonal craft
One of the five other Marines messaged him to 'shut up' and not bother him, and Herrera forwarded that message to Senate Intel; another emailed after his Shawn Ryan interview to thank him 'for getting the word out'. He says he has 'receipts' of both.firsthandMichael Herrera
He gave all their names to SSCI, SASC and AARO; none has been subpoenaed, and he was told they count as 'incidental witnesses'.firsthandSumatra, 2009: Michael Herrera's octagonal craftAARO
Photographs of him driving to work were sent to his house; he notified people about it. Helicopters have also hovered over his father's home, his own and his business.firsthandMichael Herrera
Department of Homeland Security agents approached him and took a statement, interested in the human-trafficking side of what he saw.firsthandMichael Herrera
Coulthart: "I think Michael Herrera is telling the truth. In fact I know Michael Herrera is telling the truth", and so does Jake Barber; later, "if you are telling the truth, and I think you are".analysis

Alleged / one person's word

Coulthart: Jake Barber identified Herrera's containers as the kind he saw at 'the range', used to transport psionics, and told his government contacts so. Herrera: 'Correct.'secondhandJake Barber → Michael Herrera / Ross Coulthart (Reality Check, 2025) → told itSumatra, 2009: Michael Herrera's octagonal craftJake Barber
Engineers who built such craft have contacted him; he has seen their credentials and they sent documents, and he is asking them to wait until protections exist.anonymousunnamed program engineers → Michael Herrera → told itMichael Herrera
People 'on the back end' confirmed the logistics of Weygandt's 1997 Peru event, and the Department of Energy 'may have played a role', with its own private military contractors to 'conceal stuff or go retrieve things'.anonymousunnamed people 'on the back end' → Michael Herrera → told itThe crashed egg in Peru (Weygandt, 1997)Jonathan Weygandt

Sources

Want to dig?

The Workspace has every case, person, document and episode, with the board, the atlas, timelines and the threads between them.

Open the Workspace →
Sources include war.gov/ufo (PURSUE), the FBI Vault, NASA and ASU Apollo archives, congressional testimony and the witnesses' own words. Each case links to its sources.A research project · updated 22 November 2026 · Privacy