UAP Trail Workspace
458 cases · 37 threads
Show
Narrative
The cover layer
Narrative

The cover layer

Deception is a branch of its own, and it grows after every wave of sightings. Robertson called for debunking in 1953; Kirtland produced Bennewitz, Doty and MJ-12; then came the forged Ellsworth document, the Wilson-Davis notes, the disclosure study and Kona Blue. Each narrator mentions one piece; none lays out the whole arc.

Cross-source readingPlausibility to rate
Reader view →
1

The voices it opens with

Before UAP Trail says a word, the video lets others speak. Each clip is linked at its second in the video.

Richard Doty
AFOSI agent
His job was to spread false UFO stories, including to Paul Bennewitz.
Named witness
Department of Homeland Security
on Kona Blue
No data or material of any kind was ever transferred to or collected by DHS under the auspices of KONA BLUE.
On the record
2

The claim, in UAP Trail’s words

“The noise is part of the signal: each wave of sightings is followed by a matching layer of deception.”

Our reading across 14 records

3

How it split

The central claim drawn as a tree. Each branch is a part of the story that went its own way, splitting at UAP Trail’s turning points. Line weight is UAP Trail’s sense of how much each branch holds. Click a branch, a fork or a dot.

On the recordNamed witnessUnnamed insidersUAP Trail’s reasoningFork: what split it
DEBUNKINGPLANTEDADMIT, DENY19351940194519501955196019651970197519801985199019952000200520102015202020251933 · Magenta telegramsWHERE IT IS NOWPlanted papersExposed, still circulatingOfficial policyAAROPrograms admitted, then deniedContested1980 · Kirtland1980 · Kirtland2002 · Wilson-Davis2002 · Wilson-Davis1983 · Doty's job: false stories1984 · The MJ-12 papers1989 · The forged Ellsworth L-9 document1995 · Roswell records destroyed1947 · Twining: 'real and not visionary'1949 · Study 203: "some object has been seen"1949 · Grudge: 'migrating birds'1953 · Battelle to 'reassure the public'1953 · The Robertson Panel: debunkThe Robertson Panel: debu…1953 · AFR 200-2: real reports go elsewhere1954 · OPNAV 3820: Navy reports to intelligence1954 · JANAP 146C: the 1954 reporting clampJANAP 146C: the 1954 repo…1965 · Kecksburg: 'Acme' meteor, tapes takenKecksburg: 'Acme' meteor,…1966 · Low's 'trick' memoLow's 'trick' memo1969 · Blue Book closes1978 · Coyame: the CIA warns Stringfield off Mexico2023 · AARO's first annual report2005 · A study on the effects of disclosure2011 · Kona BlueKona Blue
1947–now

Official policy

This branch rests on: on the record
What the government says out loud.
What it held. Study 203, Robertson, Blue Book, AARO.
Where it is now. AARO
Events on this branch
4

How it unfolds: three eras

1947–1979

Debunking

Study 203 and Robertson set the public line.
12 events · 11 record · 1 named · 0 unnamed · 0 reasoning
1980–1999

Planted papers

Kirtland, MJ-12 and the forgeries.
5 events · 2 record · 2 named · 1 unnamed · 0 reasoning
2000–now

Admit and deny

Programs leak, are confirmed in part, then explained away.
4 events · 2 record · 2 named · 0 unnamed · 0 reasoning
5

What carries it

Every event in the narrative, sorted by what it rests on. The on-record events are the skeleton; the rest is what UAP Trail hangs on it.

15On the recordLaws, orders, founding dates, released files
5Named witnessesPeople on record, firsthand or secondhand
1Unnamed insidersUAP Trail’s own sources, anonymous to the public
0UAP Trail’s reasoningThe links and readings UAP Trail adds
A research project by Igor FrancePrivacy