2024 · Near LaGuardia Airport, New York City, from a passenger aircraft

A cylinder past the window near LaGuardia, filmed by a passenger (2024)

Sourced, unconfirmed
Strength D · 4/10 · 2 independent
Evidence 1/4 · Witnesses 2/3 · Backing 1/3

A named passenger's own video, a second passenger who reports seeing it, and an investigator who found no sign of a fake; five frames of phone video, no flight, date or original file published.

Plausibility Moderate
Score 8 · 7 factors for, 0 against

A named witness with video who sought an explanation before going public, and a second passenger; held back by five frames, an unconfirmed date and flight, and an analysis that was only beginning.

See the factors ↓

Unresolved
A frame of Michelle Reyes's video from her window seat near LaGuardia: the dark cylinder above the New York skyline. · Michelle Reyes (video, as aired by NewsNation)

In spring 2024 Michelle Reyes, a passenger flying over New York with her daughter, filmed the skyline from her window and caught a cylinder crossing outside the aircraft near LaGuardia. Investigator Ben Hansen found no sign that the video was faked, and another mother on the same flight says she saw the object too.

The object is in five frames, crossing her view in about a seventh of a second. Hansen puts it at more than 200 mph and says the insect explanation has problems. The image is "very clear", he told NewsNation, which he called unusual. The presenter compared it to the Navy's Tic Tac.

I find no evidence that she faked this or hoaxed it.
Ben Hansen, UFO Witness, on NewsNation

What she did next

Reyes played the clip back, saw the object was outside the window, and emailed the FAA in case it was a safety hazard. The FAA never acknowledged her. She sent it to Enigma Labs, which answered, and to a national UFO database. Her father, a former Navy man, had no idea what it was; pressed, he guessed a drone, though one should not have been that close to an airliner. When she posted the video, one of the other mothers on the flight said she had noticed it in the air as well.

How it surfaced

Someone lifted the video from her social media and posted it as a friend's, so Hansen's team had to search flight lists to find the real filmer. They had only begun their analysis when he spoke. NewsNation reran the interview in a November 2026 airport compilation (the segment).

No explanation is offered. A drone, her father's guess, is natural cause proposed, not demonstrated.

Evidence, in date order

  1. 2024Michelle Reyessensor data
    Phone video of the pass, five frames long Shown on NewsNation
  2. 2024Ben Hansen (UFO Witness)analysis
    Analysis finding no sign of a hoax NewsNation interview

How plausible · Moderate

A named witness with video who sought an explanation before going public, and a second passenger; held back by five frames, an unconfirmed date and flight, and an analysis that was only beginning.

  • ●●
    Access She filmed it from her seat.
  • ●○
    Cost of speaking Went on national television under her name.
  • ●○
    No gain sought No gain evident; she reported it to the FAA first.
  • ●○
    Restraint Claims no origin; her father's drone guess is passed on.
  • ●○
    Checkable details check out The flight could be traced; the original file has not been published.
  • ●○
    Independent convergence A second passenger, unnamed, says she saw it.

Plausibility weighs how well an account fits where secrecy hides the documents by design, so missing records never count against it. Strength measures what is documented. Assessed 2026-11-18.

Claims

Filming the New York skyline from her window seat with her daughter beside her, Michelle Reyes caught a cylinder-shaped object crossing outside the aircraft near LaGuardia; playing the video back, she found it was outside the plane and moving very fast.NewsNation: airport sightings, from a passenger's LaGuardia video to drones over GabreskifirsthandSourced, unconfirmedMichelle Reyes, NewsNation
Another mother on the same flight saw the video on Reyes's social media and said she had noticed the object in the air too.NewsNation: airport sightings, from a passenger's LaGuardia video to drones over GabreskisecondhandSourced, unconfirmedMichelle Reyes, NewsNation
Ben Hansen of UFO Witness, who analysed the video: "I find no evidence that she faked this or hoaxed it." The object is in five frames, passes in about a seventh of a second at an estimated 200-plus mph, and an insect has problems as an explanation.NewsNation: airport sightings, from a passenger's LaGuardia video to drones over GabreskianalysisSourced, unconfirmedBen Hansen, NewsNation
She emailed the FAA as a possible safety hazard and got no acknowledgement; she sent the video to Enigma Labs, which answered, and to a national UFO database.NewsNation: airport sightings, from a passenger's LaGuardia video to drones over GabreskiEnigma LabsfirsthandSourced, unconfirmedMichelle Reyes, NewsNation
Her father, a former Navy man, had no idea what it was; if he had to guess he would say a drone, but one should not have been that close to the aircraft.secondhandSourced, unconfirmedMichelle Reyes, NewsNation
The video spread after someone took it from her social media and posted it as a friend's; Hansen's team tracked flights to find her.firsthandSourced, unconfirmedBen Hansen, NewsNation

Connected cases

People and organizations

Sources

Similar and linked cases

Want to dig?

The Workspace has every case, person, document and episode, with the board, the atlas, timelines and the threads between them.

Open the Workspace →
Sources include war.gov/ufo (PURSUE), the FBI Vault, NASA and ASU Apollo archives, congressional testimony and the witnesses' own words. Each case links to its sources.A research project · updated 22 November 2026 · Privacy