1956 · Over the Ube area, Yamaguchi, Japan, near the Shimonoseki strait between Honshu and Kyushu, about 50 nautical miles from the controlling GCI site on Mi-shima

Ube: an F-86D pilot locks on to a golden-tan "upper half of a sphere" that leaves at 1,500 knots (Japan, 1956)

On the record
Strength B · 7/10 · 3 independent
Evidence 3/4 · Witnesses 2/3 · Backing 2/3

An intelligence report from a debriefing, with airborne radar lock, a visual sighting by a named pilot, aircraft checks and unit statements; the wingman's radar and ground radar did not show it.

Plausibility High
Score 14 · 8 factors for, 0 against

A named, experienced interceptor pilot had radar lock and eyes on the same object, the officers who debriefed him found him sober and embarrassed, and they warned against reading much into the empty ground scopes.

See the factors ↓

Unidentified

On 17 December 1956 a US Air Force F-86D pilot flying practice intercepts near Ube, in southern Japan, held a radar return as big as a B-29's for seven to eight minutes, saw a small golden-tan dome where the radar put it, and watched the return leave at an estimated 1,500 to 1,800 knots. The Far East Air Forces report on the chase, IR-12-57, gives no explanation. It is DOW-UAP-D205 in PURSUE Release 08, published in November 2026.

Two captains of the Air Technical Intelligence Liaison Office of Far East Air Forces, Alan G. Pound and William J. Buchanan, wrote the report from a debriefing and dated it 20 February 1957. Colonel Harry J. Kieling approved it, rated B-2, and sent copies to Wright-Patterson, Air Defense Command and the 5th Air Force. It names the pilots: 1st Lts R. N. Brumet and R. A. Sneary of the 68th Fighter-Interceptor Squadron at Itazuke.

A blip the size of a bomber

At about 15:20 local, Brumet was making a beam attack on Sneary on a heading of about 270 degrees, under ground-controlled intercept from about 50 nautical miles away. His E-4 radar painted Sneary 20 degrees left at 12 miles. At the same moment a second, larger blip appeared 30 degrees left at 20 miles, "similar in size to that expected from a B-29 at comparable range". As he closed on Sneary the unknown stayed at 20 miles. The controllers said they had nothing there. He asked for permission to identify it and got it.

The dome

The moment he turned toward it, his radar showed a closure rate of 600 to 700 knots. At eight miles he looked and saw something in the right place: the size of a pencil eraser on his windscreen, rounded on top, "circular on the bottom", golden tan. The sun was placed to glint off metal, and there was no glint. Interference pulses ran down his scope, like a weaker version of the jamming from the B-36 and B-47 bombers he had trained against. At four to five miles it sat dead ahead, and he could get no closer. It seemed to make a shallow left turn.

Gone off the top of the scope

Then the return moved "up and away" at 1,500 to 1,800 knots, roughly 1,700 to 2,100 mph. The report stresses that this is an estimate, because the speed was "considerably faster than the radar set can indicate negative rate of closure." Sneary, four to five miles behind, had Brumet on his radar but not the object. His set showed only "a cluster of small bright pin point spots stationary and level at 12 miles range."

What the investigators checked

Another pilot flew Brumet's jet on its next sortie, and ground crews checked it after landing: all systems worked. No ground radar site reported an unidentified track. The officers add that this "should not be given much weight": the GCI site could plot even the two F-86Ds only by their IFF transponders, so a silent object would not have shown. Brumet had 1,275 flying hours, 687 of them in the F-86D. They found him conscientious, telling the story "in a straight forward, slightly embarrassed manner" and saying he would doubt it himself "if it hadn't actually happened to him."

he would doubt the possibility of such an occurrance if it hadn't actually happened to him
ATILO report IR-12-57 on 1st Lt R. N. Brumet, 1957

The story did not stay secret for long. NICAP's newsletter, the UFO Investigator, printed its substance with the names removed in the summer of 1957, and Brad Sparks later listed it among his Blue Book unknowns. Two weeks after Ube, another F-86D pilot reported a light that outclimbed and circled him over Guam.

Proposed explanation: none in the file; no cause shown.

Evidence, in date order

  1. 17 Dec 1956F-86D E-4 airborne intercept radarsensor data
    painted and locked on the return for seven to eight minutes, with closure-rate readings
  2. 1957NICAP, UFO Investigatorpress
    published the report's substance in 1957
  3. 20 Feb 195768th Fighter-Interceptor Squadron, 8th Fighter-Bomber Wing and 41st Air Divisionofficial
    written statements verifying the report, held by the FEAF ATIL office according to the report

How plausible · High

A named, experienced interceptor pilot had radar lock and eyes on the same object, the officers who debriefed him found him sober and embarrassed, and they warned against reading much into the empty ground scopes.

  • ●●
    Access He held it on his own radar and saw it where the radar said it was.
  • ●●
    No gain sought A routine training sortie with nothing to gain.
  • ●●
    Restraint The officers flag the departure speed as an estimate beyond what the set could indicate.
  • ●●
    Character record An F-86D pilot with 1,275 flying hours.
  • ●●
    Checkable details check out DOW-UAP-D205 is released in full.
  • ●●
    Physical traces or official reaction Airborne radar lock, radar interference, and a formal ATILO investigation.

Plausibility weighs how well an account fits where secrecy hides the documents by design, so missing records never count against it. Strength measures what is documented. Assessed 2026-11-21.

On the record

  • IR-12-57, DI FEAF ATILO, 20 February 1957; date of information 20 December 1956; evaluation B-2; reference AFR 200-2.
  • Written statements from the 68th FIS, the 8th Fighter-Bomber Wing and the 41st Air Division are held in the DI FEAF ATIL office, the report says.
  • A sketch map overlay to WAC 388 marks "Bogie First Seen Here" and "Bogie Last Here", with the monitoring GCI site on Mi-shima.
  • The report gives the position as 33°59'N on its first page and 33°39'N on the second, both at 131°18'E.

Claims

During practice intercepts, 1st Lt R. N. Brumet's F-86D radar painted a second, larger blip 30 degrees left at 20 miles, "similar in size to that expected from a B-29 at comparable range", while his wingman's F-86D showed at 12 miles.F-86D pilot outclimbed and circled by a light over GuamfirsthandOn the recordPilot debriefing in IR-12-57 (DOW-UAP-D205)
At about eight miles he saw an object the size and shape of a pencil eraser on his windscreen; it looked circular on the bottom, was golden tan, and gave no sun reflection although the sun was in a position to reflect off metal.firsthandOn the recordPilot debriefing, DOW-UAP-D205
His radar held it for seven to eight minutes and he saw it off and on for three to four minutes; he closed to within five miles and could not close further. After an apparent shallow left turn the return moved up and away at an estimated 1,500 to 1,800 knots, faster than the set could indicate.firsthandOn the recordPilot debriefing, DOW-UAP-D205
Interference pulses came down the radar scope, similar to but weaker than those from the ECM-equipped B-36 and B-47 bombers he had trained against.firsthandOn the recordPilot debriefing, DOW-UAP-D205
The wingman, 1st Lt R. A. Sneary, held Brumet's jet on radar but not the object; his set showed "a cluster of small bright pin point spots stationary and level at 12 miles range".firsthandOn the recordDOW-UAP-D205
The aircraft was flown again and checked by ground crews, and all systems were satisfactory; no ground radar site reported unidentified tracks.analysisOn the recordCaptains Alan G. Pound and William J. Buchanan, ATILO, DOW-UAP-D205
The preparing officers describe the pilot as conscientious, with 1,275 flying hours, 687 of them in the F-86D, reporting "in a straight forward, slightly embarrassed manner".F-86D pilot outclimbed and circled by a light over GuamanalysisOn the recordPound and Buchanan, DOW-UAP-D205
NICAP's UFO Investigator printed the substance of the report, with names removed, in its August/September 1957 issue.secondhandSourced, unconfirmedProject 1947 reprint of the UFO Investigator article
Brad Sparks lists the case as number 1216 in his Blue Book Unknowns catalogue.secondhandSourced, unconfirmedUAP Discovery case entry, citing Sparks

Where

Over the Ube area, Yamaguchi, Japan, near the Shimonoseki strait between Honshu and Kyushu, about 50 nautical miles from the controlling GCI site on Mi-shima
36.0°N 138.0°E · region only
See it on the map

Connected cases

People and organizations

Sources

Similar and linked cases

Want to dig?

The Workspace has every case, person, document and episode, with the board, the atlas, timelines and the threads between them.

Open the Workspace →
Sources include war.gov/ufo (PURSUE), the FBI Vault, NASA and ASU Apollo archives, congressional testimony and the witnesses' own words. Each case links to its sources.A research project · updated 22 November 2026 · Privacy