Defense Science Board Task Force on Secrecy, final report (1970)
The Defense Science Board Task Force on Secrecy was a Pentagon advisory panel of senior scientists, chaired by the physicist Frederick Seitz, whose 1970 report attacked the classification of technical information. It said secrecy "may easily do far more harm than good by stifling critical discussion and review".
Its sharpest line is a number: the volume of classified scientific and technical information "could profitably be decreased by perhaps as much as 90 percent". Edward Teller sat on the panel. It is the defense establishment's own judgment that classification was holding back science inside the system as well as outside it.

Seitz led the task force in 1969 and 1970, with defense scientists such as Teller, Jack Ruina and Marshall Rosenbluth. Its argument was that secrecy hurts the side that keeps it.
Classification of technical information impedes its flow within our own system, and, may easily do far more harm than good by stifling critical discussion and review or by engendering frustration.
-- Defense Science Board Task Force on Secrecy, 1970
The 90 percent
The panel thought the volume of classified scientific and technical information could be cut by up to 90 percent, by classifying less and for shorter periods. It went further in principle: more might be gained than lost if the United States adopted "a policy of complete openness in all areas of information", unilaterally if need be. It judged that "not a practical proposal at the present time".
Why it matters here
The claim that whole areas of physics were held back by classification usually comes from outsiders. This report is the insiders saying that classification "impedes" science within the government's own system. It does not say which fields were affected, and it says nothing about gravity or UFOs. Teller had been making the same case in public since at least 1963, when he urged the US to "unilaterally abandon secrecy".
Open questions
- Which classification categories did the panel single out, and were any of its cuts carried out?
On the record
- Final Report of the Defense Science Board Task Force on Secrecy (1970), posted by FAS.
Connected
- Edward Teller personMember
- Invention Secrecy Act of 1951 (35 U.S.C. 181-188) documentSame secrecy system
- Atomic Energy Act of 1954 documentSame secrecy system