DOE decision to classify the SILEX process as Restricted Data (2001)
In June 2001 the US Department of Energy announced that it had classified parts of SILEX, a laser process for enriching uranium invented by a private Australian company, as Restricted Data under the Atomic Energy Act. It is a published case of the government taking privately developed physics into the "born secret" category.
The notice exists because a DOE rule requires one: whenever the Secretary classifies privately generated information this way, the public must be told. The rule shows the reach that UFO researchers point to. The Act covers information about nuclear materials whoever produces it, inside the government or not.

In its own words, the Secretary decided "to classify as Restricted Data certain privately generated information concerning an innovative isotope separation process for enriching uranium." The notice was signed on 19 June 2001 and printed in the Federal Register a week later. Silex Systems Limited of Australia had been developing the process, Separation of Isotopes by Laser Excitation, since 1992. USEC Inc. bought the rights to develop it in 1996.
Why there is a notice at all
DOE's rule at 10 CFR 1045.21(c) requires the Secretary to "inform the public whenever the authority to classify privately generated information as Restricted Data is exercised." The statute defines Restricted Data as all data on atomic weapons, "the production of special nuclear material" and "the use of special nuclear material in the production of energy". The second and third clauses reach reactor and isotope physics, well beyond bomb design.
Why it matters here
In the UFO story the Act is put forward as a place where recovered material could be held. Physicists who doubt it read the Act as a weapons law, and Eric Weinstein answers that they "have not actually read the acts' language at all". SILEX shows it applied in practice to laser physics from a private lab, and The Progressive case of 1979 shows it applied to a journalist's own work. Neither case involves anything anomalous. They show how far the category reaches.
Open questions
- How many other privately generated Restricted Data decisions has DOE published since the rule took effect?
On the record
- 66 FR 33954, 26 June 2001.
- 42 U.S.C. 2014(y).
Connected
- Atomic Energy Act of 1954 documentApplies
- United States v. The Progressive (1979) documentSame reach into private work
- Eric Weinstein personCited by