News show episode · Reality Check · 5 May 2026

Reality Check: Luigi Vendittelli on S4, the hillside doors and Russians at the Nevada Test Site

Reality Check episode thumbnail. · NewsNation, YouTube thumbnail

A pilot's Christmas photo of the S-4 hillside was held up as proof that Bob Lazar lied and there was nothing there. Run through forensic analysis, the same raw frame shows nine slanted doors, the first one wider, exactly as Lazar described the hangars in 1989. Filmmaker Luigi Vendittelli laid it out for Ross Coulthart, along with Lazar's claim that Russians worked at S-4 before him.

Vendittelli made S4: The Bob Lazar Story, which reached number one on Amazon Prime in the US a month before this interview. The photo is his strongest answer to the question he says he split in two: did Lazar work at a hidden facility, and was alien technology there? The doors speak only to the first.

That's not evidence of my story. That's just evidence that I knew there were doors there.
Bob Lazar, as Vendittelli quotes him

The photo that was meant to close the case

On 25 December 2020, in the depth of COVID and on a holiday, a private pilot was cleared through the restricted airspace. He flew past Groom Lake, swung round, and pointed a Nikon with a long lens straight at the hillside by Papoose Lake where Lazar put S-4. The unfiltered frame shows a hill, a dry lake and nothing else. As Coulthart sums it up, the man who shot it thought it was the clinching evidence that Lazar was a liar, and for a year it was passed around as exactly that: "There's nothing there."

Then researcher Scott Mitchell sent Vendittelli a drawing of where the doors sat on that photo, at the precise angle Vendittelli's team had modelled from Lazar's directions, USGS topography and Russian satellite data. It matched so well that Vendittelli first suspected a leak from his own team. Mitchell's point was simple: the raw image is public, sourced from the photographer online, and the detail is in it once you work the picture.

Vendittelli gave the raw file to his team, including members who "do not believe in flying saucers", and asked two things: pull out the shapes, then scan the whole image to test whether rectangles like these could be noise. Everyone confirmed nine slanted rectangles set into the curve of the hill, at the spot Lazar pointed to. And the first is slightly wider. Lazar always called the first hangar "the big hangar", the one that held the sport model. Vendittelli had forgotten that detail until he saw it in the image. How would Lazar have known it in 1989? More on the site in S-4.

Russians at S-4

Coulthart reminds viewers that Lazar has said, Rogan included, that Russians were at S-4 before him and were kicked out once a major discovery was made. "The only people from whom the existence of S4 is being hidden," Coulthart concludes, "are the American people." Vendittelli agrees. When he raised it, Lazar told him that in the late 1980s, under the Reagan and Gorbachev exchanges of scientists, some Russians were allowed onto the Nevada Test Site; whether any reached S-4, Vendittelli says, is possible but unknown.

Vendittelli has backing of his own. He catalogued 20,000 declassified EG&G photos of the test site from the 1960s to the mid-1980s, and some show Russian equipment on site, labelled in Russian. Lazar's friend John Farhat, he adds, got a Russian satellite photo of S-4 in the early 1990s and made it into a poster; it shows a silver disc in the air.

What Coulthart is told

Coulthart goes further. He says an astronaut, Tom Stafford, went to the Soviet Union during the Cold War to help retrieve a non-human craft, without saying who told him. The late Dave Fruehauf, a former SR-71 and U-2 pilot in an administrative job at Area 51, never saw Lazar there, Coulthart says, but knew people who saw him on the Janet flights in. His legacy-program sources tell him the craft are flown by mind, because they cannot be built at the material level alone; Lazar saw no controls in the sport model, Vendittelli says, though they may have been removed.

What Lazar holds back

By his account to Vendittelli, Lazar was on site for four to six months from late December 1988, one week on and two off, and keeps small details back as a test for anyone who claims to have been at S-4.

  • The book. In the briefing room lay a book with thin pages like sheet metal, though not metal, showing layered X-ray-style images that changed with the viewing angle, like the peel-back overlays of an old Collier's encyclopedia. Asked whether it was written in English, he said yes.
  • Congress. Asked whether he would testify with protection, he told Vendittelli no. He takes no money from the film, Vendittelli says.

Cases discussed

Sources

Want to dig?

The Workspace has every case, person, document and episode, with the board, the atlas, timelines and the threads between them.

Open the Workspace →
Sources include war.gov/ufo (PURSUE), the FBI Vault, NASA and ASU Apollo archives, congressional testimony and the witnesses' own words. Each case links to its sources.A research project · updated 22 November 2026 · Privacy