News show episode · Reality Check · 21 November 2026

Reality Check: the Rubber Duck, La Bruja and other border videos under the microscope

Ross Coulthart and his guest in front of the border FLIR footage. · NewsNation / Reality Check (YouTube rAX2a4pqMwI), thumbnail crop with logos and banner removed

Ross Coulthart takes the strangest infrared videos from Arizona's southern border to the scientists of the Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies at its Huntsville conference, and asks which ones hold up.

The Rubber Duck holds up best. Peter Reali, who wrote SCU's analysis, walks through the 2019 National Guard clip: a rigid two-lobed shape, no engine heat, circled for 40 minutes over a wildlife refuge, and faster than the wind at any height it could have been. "I don't know. I know it's anomalous."

La Bruja and the Cigar

La Bruja, a Border Patrol ground-truck clip from about February 2020, shows a similar cold, wingless shape gliding over cattle that never look up. Matthew Szydagis calls it "potentially anomalous" for its temperature and shape. The Cigar, filmed on a phone off an aircraft monitor, is unreadable without its metadata, and both scientists leave it open.

What the scientists threw out

SCU co-founder Rich Hoffman, a contractor on a counter-drone project at Redstone Arsenal, matched the 2022 Apache night video to birds, against a reading of Mach 1.28. An A-10 clip from Davis-Monthan (April 2021) stays inconclusive. Coulthart adds FAA reports from the area: an F-35 pilot's eight silvery objects at 16,000 to 20,000 ft in April 2022, and a Tucson police helicopter that chased an object for about an hour in 2016.

Cases discussed

The claims, checked

Alleged / one person's word

Peter Reali on the Rubber Duck: a rigid object, cold all through, circling over empty desert, faster than the wind at every altitude it could have flown. 'I don't know. I know it's anomalous.'analysisPeter Reali (SCU), to Ross CoulthartThe Rubber Duck: a cold object circled for 40 minutes over the Arizona border (2019)
La Bruja, filmed by a Border Patrol ground scope truck in about February 2020: a very cold, wingless object passing over cattle. 'potentially anomalous' because of its temperature and shape.analysisMatthew Szydagis, to Ross CoulthartThe Rubber Duck: a cold object circled for 40 minutes over the Arizona border (2019)
Rich Hoffman, an SCU co-founder who works as a contractor on a counter-drone project at Redstone Arsenal, matched the 2022 Apache night video to birds.analysisRich Hoffman (SCU), to Ross Coulthart

Sources

Want to dig?

The Workspace has every case, person, document and episode, with the board, the atlas, timelines and the threads between them.

Open the Workspace →
Sources include war.gov/ufo (PURSUE), the FBI Vault, NASA and ASU Apollo archives, congressional testimony and the witnesses' own words. Each case links to its sources.A research project · updated 22 November 2026 · Privacy