2019 · Over the Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge, southern Arizona, near the Mexican border

The Rubber Duck: a cold object circled for 40 minutes over the Arizona border (2019)

Sourced, unconfirmed
Strength D · 4/10 · 2 independent
Evidence 3/4 · Witnesses 0/3 · Backing 1/3

Long sensor video with full metadata and a published analysis; the crew have not spoken and the source is anonymous.

Plausibility Moderate
Score 9 · 7 factors for, 1 against

A military infrared camera held an object for 40 minutes with full position data, and a published analysis finds it outran the wind; the crew themselves guessed a balloon, and the source is anonymous.

See the factors ↓

Unidentified
The Rubber Duck at 13:57 into the recording. The object is the white shape just right of the crosshair; in this black-hot mode, white means cold. · Arizona Air National Guard FLIR video, via Peter Reali / SCU on Zenodo (CC BY 4.0), centre crop 2x

A cold, rubber-duck-shaped object that an Air National Guard spy plane on a Border Patrol drug flight followed with its infrared camera for 40 minutes over the Arizona desert in 2019, filed as a small drone, and judged by a 2022 scientific analysis to fit no known aircraft or balloon.

The plane was hunting a group of migrants near the Mexican border. Its sensor operator, who was also the commander of the counter-drug unit, locked the FLIR camera on something else: a two-lobed shape that rocked back and forth and kept coming back to the same pose, showing no hot engine anywhere. The RC-26B circled it for about 40 minutes. Agents on the ground were asked to get eyes on it, and none could. Then the plane ran short of fuel and went home.

Filed and forgotten

The video went to the sector's intelligence unit and sat in a SCIF for about two weeks. The verdict: no link to smuggling. It came back, the official report called it a small unmanned aircraft, and the clip lived on a shared drive. The crew thought a party balloon. The sensor operator was less sure: he thought it might be Mylar, but "couldn't say for certain because of its behavior and shape", and it seemed to cruise through canyons. One of his teammates later passed it to the podcaster Andy Marcial.

Faster than the wind

Peter Reali of the Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies (SCU) worked through the camera's on-screen data: the plane's position, altitude and heading, the camera's angles and range. With weather-balloon wind soundings from the region, he computed the object's speed at every altitude it could have been at. At each one it beat the wind, even with 30% error bars, and the crew's account says it went against the wind. His conclusion: "the object cannot be explained by any known natural phenomenon or technology that is used for aeronautical propulsion." A team member flew Mylar balloons for comparison; they wobbled and flashed hot and cold, nothing like this.

On Reality Check in 2026 he put it plainly: "I don't know. I know it's anomalous."

Its cold twin

A second Border Patrol clip, "La Bruja" (the witch), was shot from a ground scope truck in about February 2020. A similar wingless, very cold shape slides past cattle, which never look up. Matthew Szydagis of the University at Albany calls it "potentially anomalous" for its temperature and shape.

Prosaic view: a balloon or a small drone, as the crew and the official report thought. Natural cause proposed, not demonstrated. Reali's own paper notes that the cold look could be a sensor artifact, a shiny surface reflecting the night sky.

Evidence, in date order

  1. Dec 2019US Border Patrol sector intelligence unitofficial
    reviewed the video in a SCIF and found no link to smuggling (per the source)
  2. Nov 2022Scientific Coalition for UAP Studiesdocument
    forensic analysis of the two clips and their metadata Reali (2022), doi 10.5281/zenodo.7301342

How plausible · Moderate

A military infrared camera held an object for 40 minutes with full position data, and a published analysis finds it outran the wind; the crew themselves guessed a balloon, and the source is anonymous.

  • ●●
    No gain sought The source stayed anonymous and asked for nothing.
  • ●●
    Checkable details check out Both clips and their metadata are public with the paper.
  • ●●
    Physical traces or official reaction 60 minutes of FLIR video with position, altitude and range data.
  • ●○
    Access The sensor operator filmed it; we hear him through a colleague.
  • ●○
    Restraint The crew offered a balloon, not a craft.
  • ●○
    Fits the documented skeleton Fits other cold, wingless infrared objects filmed over the southern border.
Against
  • −
    Contradicted by an insider The official report recorded a small drone, and the crew guessed a party balloon.

Plausibility weighs how well an account fits where secrecy hides the documents by design, so missing records never count against it. Strength measures what is documented. Assessed 2026-11-22.

Claims

An Arizona Air National Guard RC-26B on a Border Patrol counter-drug flight filmed an object with its FLIR camera on 23 November 2019 and followed it for about 40 minutes over the Buenos Aires refuge, until fuel and mission time ran out. The two 30-minute clips carry the camera's date, time and position.secondhandSourced, unconfirmedanonymous Border Patrol source, via Andy Marcial and SCU (Reali 2022, Appendix F)
The video went to the sector intelligence unit, which kept it in a SCIF for about two weeks, found no link to smuggling and released it; the official report filed with it recorded a small unmanned aerial system. The camera operator thought it might be a Mylar balloon but could not say, given its behaviour and shape, and found it odd that it seemed to cruise through canyons.secondhandSourced, unconfirmedanonymous Border Patrol source, narrative of 20 June 2021 and text messages (Reali 2022, Appendix F)
SCU's forensic analysis concludes that 'the object cannot be explained by any known natural phenomenon or technology that is used for aeronautical propulsion': a rigid shape that rocks and returns to the same orientation, no heat from any engine, and a ground speed above the measured winds at every possible altitude, even with wide error bars.analysisOn the recordPeter Reali, Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies, monograph (Zenodo, 8 Nov 2022)
The object looks colder than the ground, but the paper itself warns this may be a sensor artifact, a metallic surface reflecting the cold sky, as a Mylar balloon would.analysisOn the recordPeter Reali, SCU (2022), observable 3 and Appendix B
Of the object, on Reality Check: 'I don't know. I know it's anomalous.'Reality Check: the Rubber Duck, La Bruja and other border videos under the microscopeanalysisSourced, unconfirmedPeter Reali, to Ross Coulthart (Reality Check, posted 21 Nov 2026)
A second Border Patrol thermal clip, 'La Bruja' (the witch), filmed from a ground scope truck in about February 2020, shows a similar cold, wingless object passing over cattle that ignore it. Matthew Szydagis calls it 'potentially anomalous' because of its temperature and shape.Reality Check: the Rubber Duck, La Bruja and other border videos under the microscopeAguadilla Thermal VideoanalysisSourced, unconfirmedMatthew Szydagis and Peter Reali, on Reality Check (posted 21 Nov 2026)

Connected cases

People and organizations

Sources

Heard in

Similar and linked cases

Want to dig?

The Workspace has every case, person, document and episode, with the board, the atlas, timelines and the threads between them.

Open the Workspace →
Sources include war.gov/ufo (PURSUE), the FBI Vault, NASA and ASU Apollo archives, congressional testimony and the witnesses' own words. Each case links to its sources.A research project · updated 22 November 2026 · Privacy