Person

Jonathan Caplan

Jonathan Caplan is a senior British barrister, a King's Counsel, and author of *Not For Disclosure: UFOs: The World's Best Kept Secret* (2026), who speaks on UAP at conferences and on podcasts. His central claim is that Britain and the other Five Eyes allies have deferred to the United States on the subject since 1947, down to handing over any craft that comes down on their soil, and one of his claims, a 2023 Five Eyes UAP caucus, is borne out by a UK tribunal record.

Caplan brings a barrister's standing and fifty years of inside stories to the subject. He sat on the board of Flying Saucer Review from the late 1960s, met Jacques Vallée, Stanton Friedman and John Mack through it, and says he has collected what people in government service told him ever since. Some of what he says is his own memory, much he passes on from sources he does not name, and he attaches his own caveats.

The Americans collect

The Five Eyes "all defer to the US on this subject", Caplan told WEAPONIZED in November 2026, and he traces it to Forrestal's meeting with Sir Henry Tizard on 1 October 1947. A Five Eyes UAP working party met recently at the Pentagon, he says. His sources tell him that when an anomalous object comes down in a partner country, that country's special forces secure the site, in effect under American command, and the United States comes to collect it, not always quickly: "we have to wait for our ambulance service here". He has seen no written order. Has it happened in Britain? "Almost certainly yes", he says, pointing to the Brecon Beacons in Wales, where witnesses believe craft have come down and "there is some evidence from some special forces" of recovery missions, though he cannot name a site (recovery teams).

A claim that checked out

At the Stockholm Beyond conference in October 2026, where he gave the keynote (the event), Caplan said a Five Eyes UAP caucus at the Pentagon was first convened in May 2023 and had just been revived. A UK tribunal ruling records a "FVEY Inaugural UAP Caucus Working Group" on 24 May 2023 (Gomez recap). Since the book came out, he says, MPs have contacted him wanting the UK to take the subject up; he has advised MP Clive Lewis to gather colleagues in a private room in the Commons and aim for select-committee hearings.

The palace connection

One of his tasks on Flying Saucer Review, he said on American Alchemy, was to deliver each issue to Sir Peter Horsley, Prince Philip's equerry. With Philip's consent, he says, Horsley interviewed key witnesses at the palace, wrote up a report, and the two discussed it. Among the cases he recalls are a BOAC Stratocruiser under Captain Howard, followed by a saucer that crew and passengers watched, and two Derbyshire schoolboys who photographed three saucers. He places the BOAC case in the 1960s or 70s; standard accounts put it near Goose Bay in June 1954. Horsley's own memoir, as Caplan relays it, describes a "Mr Janus" in a dim Chelsea room who seemed to read his mind and asked to meet Philip.

What his sources tell him

These are claims from people he does not name, and he presents them that way:

  • Arranged landings. A craft landed by arrangement in Russia in 1994, with "good evidence of this in intelligence circles", and President Carter, long out of office, was informed; the case is in his book. He also retells George H. W. Bush's reported account to Eric Davis of a Nordic-looking pilot meeting officers at Holloman.
  • The beings themselves. Live beings in custody have been "very deceptive" under questioning, and some of his sources say disclosure needs the consent of one or two non-human species, who have refused at least once.
  • The Corona report. One early report from the Corona site, tied to Roswell, "allegedly" found dissected human bodies in the craft. He stresses the "allegedly".
  • London. Helicopters come out quickly to surround objects over London, "even last month" (October 2026). People have sent him photographs of objects hidden in a thick, wispy green cloud in a clear night sky, with a shape visible inside when enlarged.
  • Further back. Haim Eshed's Hebrew book, which Caplan had translated, on crashes and a "Galactic Federation" agreement; treat it with caution, he says, because Eshed's source is unknown, and Paul Hellyer told him he did not believe the Federation part. The CIA's Office of Global Access lent to crash retrieval, with Varginha and Weygandt in Peru as examples, "as far as I understand it". E. Howard Hunt telling Douglas Caddy that Kennedy was killed because he was about to reveal the alien presence.

The photo he withdrew

The craft photograph around page 52 of his book came from a stack of unpublished black-and-white photos found with MJ-12 material at the late Tim Cooper's house, which Ryan Wood searched again at Caplan's prompting. The book said he could not source it. It turned out to be an adapted still from The Day the Earth Stood Still. "I have a lot of egg on my face," he says; it comes out of the paperback. The same search produced new MJ-12 documents, which are in the book and which he says he checked against contemporary diaries. He stands by every word of the text.

The lawyer behind it

His co-written Confessions (1977) reinvestigated a murder conviction built on three boys' confessions taken with no responsible adult present; it led to a public inquiry and to the creation of the Crown Prosecution Service. He has been bugged on a case, not UFO-related, and received an apology from the Attorney General, and he defended a leaker of official secrets whom a jury acquitted on the argument that ministers must tell Parliament the truth. His rule for testimony, he says, is to look for corroboration and for the data, which intelligence agencies seize because "you can't discredit the data".

Open questions

  • Horsley's memoir, Sounds from Another Room, for the Janus meeting and the palace interviews. His Forrestal diary chain to the British Flying Saucer Working Party does not fit its 1950 to 1951 dates.
  • What source does his book give for the 1994 Russian landing, and why would Carter, out of office, be told?
  • Who took the London green-cloud photographs, and when?

Claims

About 50 years ago he sat on the editorial board of Flying Saucer Review, and one of his tasks was to deliver each issue to Prince Philip's equerry. With Philip's consent and full knowledge, the equerry interviewed key witnesses to significant UFO events at the palace, wrote up a transcript or report, and the two discussed it.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officefirsthandSourced, unconfirmedJonathan Caplan
Among the cases taken up at the palace he recalls a BOAC Stratocruiser under Captain Howard, on a flight from New York, followed by a flying saucer that crew and passengers watched; and two Derbyshire schoolboys who photographed three saucers and were asked about the circumstances.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officefirsthandSourced, unconfirmedJonathan Caplan
The equerry, Sir Peter Horsley, wrote in Sounds from Another Room that an army general sent him to a Mrs Markham in Chelsea, where a 'Mr Janus' in a dimly lit room questioned him about Prince Philip and UFOs, seemed to read his mind and told him things he knew only from the RAF and the palace, and asked to be introduced to Philip. Horsley thought him non-human; Philip did not make the introduction, and when Horsley went back Mrs Markham had moved.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officesecondhandSourced, unconfirmedSir Peter Horsley
A craft is said to have landed on Lord Mountbatten's Broadlands estate and been seen by the gardener, whom Mountbatten interviewed and passed on to Prince Philip. With Timothy Good, and from another source he will not name, Caplan suspects Mountbatten was the 'very senior cabinet' source for Dorothy Kilgallen's 1955 London story of a crashed craft with small humanoids aboard.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officeanonymousLeadJonathan Caplan
He will not discuss living royals but believes King Charles is interested, and from conversations he has been privy to he thinks Monaco's ruling family, like Liechtenstein's, takes 'an active interest'.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officeanonymousLeadJonathan Caplan
Haim Eshed, founder of Israel's space programme, published Beyond the Horizon in Hebrew in December 2020 with a journalist co-author and gave one newspaper interview before publication describing crashes, non-human intelligence, and agreements between the United States, Israel, Britain, Japan and one or two other countries and a 'Galactic Federation'. Caplan had the book translated: it also covers little-known crashes and Eshed's reading of Mars rover photos. Eshed and the co-author then refused all contact, and the book has never appeared in English.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officesecondhandLeadHaim Eshed
Shortly before he died, Paul Hellyer told Caplan he did not believe the Galactic Federation part of Eshed's account.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officesecondhandSourced, unconfirmedPaul Hellyer
Truman's and Forrestal's diaries show Truman, Forrestal and Bush meeting at 11:30 a.m. on 24 September 1947, the date of the alleged MJ-12 directive; Forrestal's diary shows him and Bush meeting Sir Henry Tizard on 1 October 1947 and, in October, three senior RAF officers. Caplan links this to Tizard's Flying Saucer Working Party, whose single-copy report followed 'the lead from the Americans' that the subject get as little publicity as possible.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officeanalysisLeadJonathan Caplan
The CIA's Office of Global Access, since renamed, moves people or items into and out of difficult jurisdictions and was lent to crash retrieval; he gives Varginha (an American aircraft at Campinas) and Weygandt in Peru as examples. In Five Eyes countries, national special forces under American command isolate a crash site and wait for the Americans to collect.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officeCentral Intelligence AgencyVarginha: the "ET de Varginha" and the Army inquiryThe crashed egg in Peru (Weygandt, 1997)The recovery teamsanalysisLeadJonathan Caplan
Before going to prison, E. Howard Hunt took his former lawyer Douglas Caddy to dinner and told him Kennedy was killed because he was about to reveal the alien presence.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officesecondhandLeadE. Howard Hunt
Since his book came out, a number of members of parliament have contacted him wanting the UK to take up the subject; there is no public UK policy or programme, and Britain will defer to the Americans.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officefirsthandSourced, unconfirmedJonathan Caplan
There have been many instances, 'even last month' (October 2026), of a sighting over London where helicopters come out quickly to surround the object and see it off or find out what it is.Jonathan Caplan KC: Prince Philip, Eshed and the CIA's retrieval officeStockholm UAP conference (Beyond Session #1, 1 Oct 2026)anonymousLeadJonathan Caplan
His sources say a Five Eyes UAP working party shares information, mainly from the United States, and met recently at the Pentagon. If an anomalous object comes down in a partner country, that country's special forces secure the site, in effect under American command, and the United States is 'the collecting agency'; the Americans can take a long time to arrive, 'like you know, we have to wait for our ambulance service here'.WEAPONIZED: Jonathan Caplan KC on Britain, the Five Eyes and who collects a crashed craftThe recovery teamsanonymousLeadJonathan Caplan
Craft have almost certainly come down in Britain, particularly in the Brecon Beacons in Wales, where witness evidence points to it and 'there is some evidence from some special forces' that they went on recovery missions; he cannot point to a crash site.WEAPONIZED: Jonathan Caplan KC on Britain, the Five Eyes and who collects a crashed craftanonymousLeadJonathan Caplan

Cases

Connected

Sources

Heard in

Want to dig?

The Workspace has every case, person, document and episode, with the board, the atlas, timelines and the threads between them.

Open the Workspace →
Sources include war.gov/ufo (PURSUE), the FBI Vault, NASA and ASU Apollo archives, congressional testimony and the witnesses' own words. Each case links to its sources.A research project · updated 22 November 2026 · Privacy